The
Zona Pellucida is a glycoprotein layer that involves the oocyte.
It is believed that this non cellular structure is produced by the
oocyte and by the cells that wrap the oocyte during its follicular
development. It consists of two layers: one external, thick layer
which is easily dissolved during AHA; and one internal thin layer
which is harder to penetrate. During “in vitro” culture,
the zona pellucida becomes fragile and loses its elasticity due
to a process named zona hardening. This process causes a blockage
against fertilization by polyspermy, creating a mechanism to protect
the pre-embryo.
FUNCTIONS
OF ZONA PELLUCIDA
The zona pellucida
is a physical barrier that serves the function of protecting the
oocytes and pre-embryos against antigens during the pre-implantation
period;
The zona pellucida is important during oocyte/spermatozoon interaction
because of the receptors for spermatozoa on the oocyte superficies;
a zona having non functional receptors for sperm may inhibit teh
spermatozoon coupling and thus result in a fertilization failure
(indication for ICSI);
The zona pellucida of a normal oocyte prevents the penetration of
an additional spermatozoon when one has already penetrated the oolem
(blocking for polyspery); thus, oocytes fertilized in the absence
of a healthy zona pellucida showed polyspermy, and tha zona pellucida
preserves the pre-embryo tri-dimensional structure and integrity.
Abnormalities
in structure and function of the glycoprotein structure complex
may result in the impairment of fertilization, diminished viability
of the pre-embryo and a poor prognostic for implantation. By creating
an artificial hole on the oocyte superficies before implantation
(AHA) it appears that natural hatching can be facilitated and make
it easier for the pre-embryo with low potential for implantation
to be retrieved.
INDICATION
FOR ASSISTED HATCHING
1
- Highly thick zona pellucida
The
thicknes of the zona pellucida varies during the oocyte or pre-embryo
development. Thinning begins between the first and second cleavage,
and continues progressively during blastocyst formation. In the
absence of this thinning, possibly caused by absence of proteases,
the pre-embryo may remain caught inside the zona, effectively abolishing
any potential for implantation. As has been already described, the
creation of an artificial hole in the thick zona (> 15 mm) may
favour the natural hatching and the pre-embyo implantation.
2-
Abnormal form of the zona pellucida/pre-embryo
Oocytes
and pre-embryos showing an oval form are not rare. However, these
morules’ ability to become compact and develop to an “in
vitro” hatching was slower than that ones having a normal,
rounded form. This irregular pre-embryo form is usually associated
with abnormal zona pellucida. AHA may help to promote an appropriate
cell to cell contact, compactation and hatching of these abnormal
pre-embryos.
3
- Abnormal zona pellucida color
Dark
(brown or yellow) zona pellucida is sometimes observed in vitro.
It is noted that, in some oocytes specially those post-mature ones,
the zona pellucida gets darkens and deteriorate progressively in
prolonged culture (personal observation). When this morphological
characteristic is present, the pre-embryo is considered a candidate
for AHA.
4
- Cytoplasmic fragmentation
Cytoplasmic
fragments are cytoplasmatic membrane components expelled from the
surfaces of fertilized oocytes and blastomeres of pre-embryos. The
pre-embryos having excessive fragmentation (>20%) have a lower
implantation rate than those ones without the fragmentation. In
addition, the number of fragments can affect compactation and subsequent
development of the blastocyst. Analyzing the embryos during a period
of 72 hours, it has been verified that most cytoplasmic fragments
developed between the stages of pronucleus and first or second cellular
division. This precocious cytoplasmic fragmentation may indicate
in vitro damage or intrinsic DNA abnormalities of the embryos. Fragmentation
occurring after the first cleavage tends to be less excessive and
may not impair subsequent embryo development. These fragments develop
short before blastomere division, as multiple small bubbles in the
cell membrane. While cleavage goes on, some bubbles reincorporate
to other blastomeres, while others remain actual delimitated fragments.
Occasionally, individual blastomeres may break into multiple fragments,
and that indicates cell death.
Why
do fragments occur? Many factors might be responsible. Culture conditions,
cytoplasmic competence, genetic integrity, unbalanced chromosomes
and alterations in the kariocinesis and cytocinesis.
Fragmented
pre-embryo chromosomal analyses through FISH (Fluorescent In Situ
Hybridization) indicate that more than 50% of them are abnormal,
which can justify their low implantation rates. However, it is interesting
to remark that there is no relationship between woman’s age
cytoplasmic fragmentation, as is the case for the enhanced chromosomal
abnormalities in women above 40. Light fragmentation (<10%) is
usually characterized by small fragments, and may include polar
body components, localized in a determined area. These embryos have
a high inplantation rate and AHA is not indicated.
Moderate
fragmentation (10 – 20%) is associated to irregular blastomere
form and size. If these fragments are localized in a determined
area, they may cause the death of a determined blastomere. Also,
these blastomeres may present excessive fragmentation during prolonged
culture. AHA and fragment removal are indicated for these pre-embryos,
which possess low implantation potential.
Excessive
fragmentation (> 20%) is correlated to low implantation rates.
Many women posses this type of fragmentation in all of her embryos.
Some of them may benefit from AHA associated to fragment removal.
Embryos that possess multiple big irregular fragments have extremely
low implantation rates. Big fragments are difficult to distinguish,
they can only be differentiated from the cleaved blastomeres by
visualization of a nucleus. It is true that blastomeres become smaller
and smaller after successive mitoses. Pre-embryos having those abnormal
characteristics have a poor prognostic for implantation, due to
their blocked citocinesis and reduced vitality in the culture. An
aggressive fragment removal may be done in those cases, but results
are bad.
5-
Poor morphology embryos and low growth rates
Pre-embryos
having slow growth (< 6 cells in 72 hours) have good implantation
rates after treatment with AHA, comparing to non treated embryos.
One explanation is that the “hole” in the ZP may promote
easier nutrient transportation, which makes the in vivo hatching
bettes. Another type of pre-embryo that can benefit from AHA is
the one having irregular form and size blastomeres, which means
abnormal kiticynesis, citoplasm granulation and vacuolization and
other abnormalities visible in the optical microscope.
6
- Patient’s age
The
patient’s age is clearly associated with implantation and
pregnancy success. Implantation rates fall drastically in patients
over 40 submitted to IVF. That is why AHA can be indicated exclusively
because of age (independently of the pre-embryo shape), for patients
near or over 40. With the pasing of time oocytes lose their ability
to implant, due to thickening of the zona or also endogenous systemic
factors, in such a way that older women’s pre-embryos need
AHA independently of morphology.
In
Cornell’s program there is a tendency to apply AHA routinely
in patients above 40 (1/3 to ¼ Cornell patients will be 40
or over), and most their embryos are manipulated before transference.
The clinical pregancy/ trensference rates for these patients (confirmed
by ultrasonography) exceeds 35%.
OTHER
INDICATIONS
High
FSH (> 15 mUI/ml) on day three of the cycle indicates altered
follicular reserve and ovarian physiology. This fact can affect
the oocyte and its ZP inside the follicule. It has been demonstrated
that these patients can benefit from AHA with doubling their implantation
rates when compared to patients not treated by AHA.
MOTHODOLOGY
Techniques involving the use of Tyrode’s acidic solution (AT)
with a 2.35 pH are more frequently applied to AHA. In this procedure
we utilize a minimal quantity of acidified solution to disolve a
small portion of the zona. If embryo exposition to this solution
is short, there will be no negative effect for them.